Being me I'm a pretty Understanding guy but, I don't believe this story for a moment. This (as he has said in the chat) 11 year old boy sits in the chat not playing the game spamming and pissing everyone off then goes into the fighting part of the arena and "accidentally" throws out his pokemon at the exact time to get in a battle with mine. At this point there could possibly be the chance of this being a coincidence but on top of that he doesn't mean to log out. ALL of this top of everything he did in the chat in the same few hours. I understand that he may just be an eleven year old boy but if he can't handle it he (in my own opinion) doesn't need to be playing on this server. As server admins (or owner) the decision is up to you and I apologize for making you go to all this work.
His ban is your call not mine